The law as it stands is almost unenforceable as shown by recent cases including one where a pub in Greenwich was threatened with prosecution when the audience stamped their feet to folk music, and a pub in Dorset where the landlord got a formal warning after pensioners sang Happy Birthday.
The difficulty for pubs is often that the cost of the licence can be up to £5,000 in some areas, a crippling extra cost for small community pubs especially if they only have live music on an occasional basis. The result is a collapse in the number of pubs with live music, particularly pubs formerly well known among musicians for informal sessions. Reform has been promised by the government, but has failed to happen due to lack of parliamentary time despite the fact that more than 200 MPs have signed an early day motion demanding urgent action.
